Depression, mourning and melancholia

An explosion of depression?

In 2017, Google’s release of the UK’s most popular search terms led ITV News to claim that Britain was among the most depressed and anxious countries in the world.

 

ITV Report on Depression

 

That same year, BBC News reported that antidepressants had become the most common treatment for depression, with prescriptions having more than doubled in the preceding decade.

 

BBC News reports on depression

 

These headlines tell us something — but not quite what they seem to. For a therapist, there is no single depression. The word functions as a catch-all, and working with it in therapy means going beyond that catch-all to understand the particular ways in which a person responds to difficult experiences of being in the world.

 

What is depression?

I invite clients to begin by describing what “depressed” or “depression” means for them, recognising that speaking about difficult subjects may not be easy. As they begin to talk, an individual life of complexity emerges from behind the catch-all term.

For some, depression describes a feeling of discontent with the world — a resignation, a withdrawal, sometimes an isolation. For others, it describes powerful feelings of despair, grief, or inconsolable sorrow. It can mean the loss of a sense of self, an experience of emptiness, or of a void that threatens to engulf. It can be marked by disgust with oneself and a relentless self-criticism. It can describe anxious, fearful, and guilty states alongside emotional flatness or blankness.

Depression can be frequent, persistent, or intermittent. It may be associated with the loss of a person, a relationship, a career — or something less tangible: the loss of a belief, an ideal, a faith.

As this suggests, the idea of a single and uniform depression implied by news headlines is probably misleading. Two examples may help to show why.

 

 

Identity and loss

Some of our strongest emotional ties come about through identifying with a person, object, situation, or belief. Identification is powerful because it produces a sense of self — of who or what we are.

Advertisers understand this well. What often makes a campaign successful is the degree to which it leads us to recognise ourselves in the product being advertised: we identify as a Caffe Nero rather than a Starbucks person, a Persil rather than an Ariel person. The brand becomes, briefly, a mirror.

When we experience a significant loss, we lose an identification — a sense of who or what we are, and of who we were for them. Grief is our response to that loss, and mourning is the unsettling and often painful process of working through.

 

Mourning

Mourning requires other people — someone with whom we can acknowledge and memorialise what has been lost.

In his 1893 painting Death in the Sickroom, Edvard Munch points to both the social and individual dimensions of mourning. A death has just occurred. The family members are isolated, turned away from one another, avoiding eye contact. And yet a connection between them persists — acknowledged through the mirroring of bodily posture and gesture.

The figure at the far left and the figure at the far right share an identical posture — a doubling that holds them together even as each turns inwards. At the centre, the woman who faces outward merges with the man directly behind her. And across the full depth of the painting, the hands of the seated woman in the foreground are echoed by those of the bearded man in the background.

Munch's Death in the Sickroom
Edvard Munch, Death in the Sickroom, 1893. Oil on canvas, 134.5 x 160 cm. National Museum, Oslo.

When there is no one to support our mourning, or when asking for support is not possible, mourning can become protracted. The depressed feelings that belong to grief may then become overwhelming. Working with a therapist can create a space in which mourning becomes possible.

 

 

 

Melancholy

Some people describe depressed feelings that are long-standing and difficult to attribute to a cause. It is as if a shadow had fallen over them, as though the sun had become eclipsed.

Albrecht Dürer’s 1514 engraving Melancholia I gives this a face. In the foreground sits the winged figure of Melancholia, hemmed in, darkened, motionless. The details around her form a catalogue of depressed feeling — not of mourning, but of something older and less tractable.

 

Durer's Melancholia
Albrecht Durer, Melancholia 1, 1514. Engraving, 24 x 19 cm.

 

The dog, a symbol in Western art of our identification with others, is shown shrivelled, half-starved, eyes closed. The tools of craft, art, and science are strewn across the floor like rubbish, drained of significance. Almost everything in the scene is static — the scales, the bell, the figure herself. Only the hourglass moves, its sand falling in equal measure from each chamber: time passes, and nothing happens. Life and non-life are not easily distinguished.

Depression and time

John Dowland’s song In Darkness Let Me Dwell catches something of the same experience:

Thus, wedded to my woes and bedded to my tomb,
O let me Living die, till death do come.

Here the earlier suspension between life and non-life has found its phrase: ‘living die.’

Melancholics are unable to separate from what has been lost — as can happen through mourning — because they have identified with loss itself. This experience can be painful, invasive, even ravaging.

If the melancholic has identified with loss itself, therapy may offer the possibility of separation from it — and with that, perhaps, the tools of craft, art, and science begin to matter again.

 

Depression and therapy

Mourning and melancholy are distinct processes, each with its own character and its own demands. This is one reason why there is no standard or uniform depression of the kind implied by news headlines. What presents under that single word may be any number of different things — and therapy involves finding out which.

 

Melancholia’s dog?

The reports of an explosion of depression in 2017 covered a period that also saw a significant escalation in homelessness across the UK. Five hundred years after Dürer made his engraving, his dog — shrivelled, half-starved, eyes closed — is not difficult to find. It sits beside the homeless and those who beg in our towns and cities, bound to its owner by the same identification Dürer understood: the animal as the emblem of a life that has lost its footing in the world.

The similarities between Dürer’s image and news photographs of the homeless invite reflection. What the headlines call an epidemic of depression may also be, in part, a picture of what happens when mourning has nowhere to go — when the losses that accumulate in a life find no social form, no one to witness them, no space in which they can be worked through.

Dürer’s melancholic sits surrounded by the tools of human endeavour, rendered useless. The homeless person sits surrounded by the tools of daily life, rendered equally useless by circumstance. Both are hemmed in. Both are waiting for something that does not come.

 

Photograph of homeless man with dog
Jon, Homeless Man and his Dog, 2013

 

Notes

The ITV News story is here (accessed 14/05/18),
http://www.itv.com/news/2017-05-10/britain-is-the-seventh-most-depressed-country-in-the-world-search-data-suggests/

The BBC chart is here (accessed 14/05/18),
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-41125009

Churchill’s description of his depression as his ‘black dog’ has become the most widely recognised use of the symbol.

It is Harrison Birtwistle who references John Dowland’s song (accessed 15/05/18),
https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2003/aug/30/art.proms2003

The photograph, ‘Homeless Man and his Dog’ (2013) by Jon, is taken from (accessed 15/05/18, pixelation added),
flickr.com/photos/jb-london/8729276154

The report of an escalation in homelessness is found in The JRF’s Homeless Monitor: England 2018,
https://www.jrf.org.uk/report/homelessness-monitor-england-2018

The distinction this article draws between mourning and melancholy is explored further in Darian Leader’s The New Black (2008).